I can’t get it to click the icon. does the image icon file need to be exactly the same size?
Yes, the image need to create it with your monitor and resolution.
@maxhodges Can you please post a screenshot of the situation? Also, what error message do you get?
No. You can also search e. g. a quarter of the icon
@newuserkantu is also correct: Best if you create the input image on the same system. But it does not have to be this way.